Ireland's hard-fought victory over Argentina showcases promising talent, defensive strength, and the need for squad evolution, setting the stage for future challenges as they navigate their path toward the Rugby World Cup.
Ireland's victory over Argentina in the November Series may have provided relief for supporters, yet it also opened up numerous points for analysis for a team with significant ambitions. The match, marked by an impressive first half and a strong defensive display in the second half, echoed lessons learned from their recent encounter with the All Blacks, raising questions about Ireland's adaptability, squad depth, and preparedness for upcoming matches against Fiji and Australia. Below are five key takeaways from the game.
1. Caelan Doris Demonstrates His Potential for the Future
Caelan Doris confirmed his role as a key figure in Ireland’s leadership by providing a poised and authoritative performance. After a quiet display against New Zealand, Doris rose to the occasion when it was crucial, demonstrating his strength during key moments of the match.
Andy Farrell's vision is evident: Doris is not merely an exceptional player; he is the leader that Ireland will rely on throughout the Rugby World Cup cycle and probably beyond. His subtle yet influential approach, which reflects the changing leadership dynamics in modern rugby, stands in stark contrast to the passionate intensity of previous captains. Doris does not require grand gestures to inspire his team; his reliable performances convey everything that needs to be said.
2. Defensive Strength Supported by the Forwards
Ireland's defensive arrangement was akin to an unbreakable barricade—effective, overwhelming, and systematic. The back row, spearheaded by Josh van der Flier's impressive 24 tackles, established the groundwork for a team committed to thwarting Argentina's progress. Doris contributed 18 tackles, while Tadhg Beirne added another 15, playing a vital role in upholding their structure under pressure.
It’s important to highlight that James Ryan had another exceptional performance, making 14 tackles in just over an hour, which indicates his return to form. The forwards of Ireland consistently meet expectations, combining intense work rates with flashes of tactical brilliance, exemplified by Peter O’Mahony’s vital lineout steal.
3. Should Farrell Consider Trying New Approaches?
Farrell's dependence on his main group after the Rugby World Cup brings up concerns regarding squad rotation and player development. Well-known figures such as James Lowe, Andrew Porter, and Jack Crowley have consistently been part of the team, but now could be the perfect time to trial the upcoming generation.
With Fiji on the horizon, it’s a strong argument for bringing new energy into the team. Individuals such as Jacob Stockdale, Ryan Baird, Cormac Izuchukwu, and Jamie Osborne should be given the chance to demonstrate their capabilities at the international level. Developing depth at this stage could prove advantageous when the pressure intensifies.
4. Jack Crowley: The Catalyst Ireland Requires at Fly-Half
Jack Crowley put forth a performance that dispelled any concerns regarding his capability to direct Ireland’s backline. His try against Argentina, taking advantage of a defensive mismatch with accuracy and assurance, highlighted the instincts of a top-tier No. 10.
For an extended period, Munster—and consequently, Ireland—suffered from their continued reliance on Joey Carbery, despite his lack of consistent performances. Jack Crowley’s commitment to adjust and grow in a key position provides Ireland with a promising prospect for stability in the vital 10/12 channel.
5. The Importance of Argentina's Progress for Ireland
Argentina's ascent under Michael Cheika has been truly impressive. Their journey to the Rugby World Cup semi-finals and their competitiveness against elite teams highlight Cheika's talent for rejuvenating squads.
Felipe Contepomi, a protégé of Cheika and a cherished figure in Irish rugby, has significantly contributed to the formation of Argentina's rugby identity. His disciplined methodology and focus on personal accountability align closely with the values that Ireland holds dear.
Contepomi's achievements suggest a potential leadership position in Irish rugby—possibly as the next head coach of Leinster. His combination of tactical insight, player development skills, and cultural awareness positions him as a strong candidate for the role whenever it opens up.
