"Ireland's victory over Argentina highlights critical lessons, showcasing Caelan Doris's emerging leadership, a resilient defense, and the need for squad experimentation to prepare for upcoming challenges against Fiji and Australia."
Ireland's victory over Argentina in the November Series may have provided relief to supporters, but it also left plenty to analyze for a team with high aspirations. The match, marked by an impressive first half and a strong defensive effort in the second half, highlighted lessons learned from the recent encounter with the All Blacks, prompting inquiries about Ireland's adaptability, depth, and preparedness for upcoming challenges against Fiji and Australia. Here are five key takeaways from the match.
1. Caelan Doris Demonstrates His Potential for the Future
Caelan Doris solidified his place as a key figure in Ireland's leadership by providing a controlled and authoritative performance. After a less impactful game against New Zealand, Doris rose to the occasion when it was most crucial, demonstrating his strength in pivotal moments.
Andy Farrell’s vision is evident: Doris is not merely a notable player; he is the leader that Ireland will rely on throughout the Rugby World Cup cycle and likely into the future. His subtle yet significant approach, which reflects the evolving leadership style in modern rugby, stands in contrast to the passionate intensity of previous captains. Doris does not require grand gestures to inspire his team; his reliable performances convey everything that needs to be said.
2. Defensive Strength Reinforced by the Forwards
Ireland's defensive arrangement was akin to an unyielding blockade—effective, overwhelming, and systematic. The back row, spearheaded by Josh van der Flier's impressive 24 tackles, established the groundwork for a team intent on thwarting Argentina's progress. Doris contributed with 18 tackles, while Tadhg Beirne added 15, playing crucial roles in preserving cohesion under pressure.
James Ryan also made a significant impact with an impressive performance, recording 14 tackles in just over an hour, indicating his return to form. Ireland’s forwards reliably step up during crucial moments, combining high work rates with instances of tactical ingenuity, exemplified by Peter O’Mahony’s key lineout interception.
3. Should Farrell Consider Experimentation?
Farrell's continued dependence on his main players since the Rugby World Cup has led to inquiries about squad rotation and player development. Well-known figures such as James Lowe, Andrew Porter, and Jack Crowley have consistently featured, but now may be the perfect time to introduce the next wave of talent.
As Fiji approaches on the schedule, it presents an excellent opportunity to introduce new players into the squad. Individuals such as Jacob Stockdale, Ryan Baird, Cormac Izuchukwu, and Jamie Osborne should be given a chance to demonstrate their abilities on the international scene. Establishing depth in the team at this stage could be beneficial when the pressure intensifies.
4. Jack Crowley: The Catalyst That Ireland Requires at Fly-Half
Jack Crowley put forth a performance that dispelled any questions regarding his capability to helm Ireland’s backline. His try against Argentina, skillfully taking advantage of a defensive mismatch with both precision and confidence, highlighted the instincts of a premier No. 10.
For an extended period, Munster—and by extension, Ireland—suffered due to their reliance on Joey Carbery, despite his lack of consistent performance. Crowley’s commitment to adjust and progress in this vital position gives Ireland a promising outlook for stability in the essential 10/12 channel.
5. The Importance of Argentina's Progress for Ireland
Argentina's ascent under Michael Cheika has been truly extraordinary. The Pumas' journey to the Rugby World Cup semi-finals, coupled with their competitiveness against elite teams, highlights Cheika's talent for rejuvenating teams.
Felipe Contepomi, a protégé of Cheika and a cherished figure in Irish rugby, has been instrumental in defining Argentina's identity. His disciplined methodology and focus on individual responsibility align closely with the values that Ireland holds in high regard.
Contepomi's achievements suggest a potential future leadership position within Irish rugby—possibly as the next head coach of Leinster. His combination of tactical intelligence, skills in player development, and cultural insight positions him as an ideal candidate for the role when it becomes open.
